Saturday, November 7, 2009
Natural Acidity of Rainwater
Pure water has a pH of 7.0 (neutral); however, natural, unpolluted rainwater actually has a pH of about 5.6 (acidic).[Recall from Experiment 1 that pH is a measure of the hydrogen ion (H+) concentration.] The acidity of rainwater comes from the natural presence of three substances (CO2, NO, and SO2) found in the troposphere (the lowest layer of the atmosphere). As is seen in Table I, carbon dioxide (CO2) is present in the greatest concentration and therefore contributes the most to the natural acidity of rainwater.
Carbon dioxide, produced in the decomposition of organic material, is the primary source of acidity in unpolluted rainwater.
NOTE: Parts per million (ppm) is a common concentration measure used in environmental chemistry. The formula for ppm is given by:
Carbon dioxide reacts with water to form carbonic acid (Equation 1). Carbonic acid then dissociates to give the hydrogen ion (H+) and the hydrogen carbonate ion (HCO3-) (Equation 2). The ability of H2CO3 to deliver H+ is what classifies this molecule as an acid, thus lowering the pH of a solution.
Nitric oxide (NO), which also contributes to the natural acidity of rainwater, is formed during lightning storms by the reaction of nitrogen and oxygen, two common atmospheric gases (Equation 3). In air, NO is oxidized to nitrogen dioxide (NO2) (Equation 4), which in turn reacts with water to give nitric acid (HNO3) (Equation 5). This acid dissociates in water to yield hydrogen ions and nitrate ions (NO3-) in a reaction analagous to the dissociation of carbonic acid shown in Equation 2, again lowering the pH of the solution.
Acidity of Polluted Rainwater
Unfortunately, human industrial activity produces additional acid-forming compounds in far greater quantities than the natural sources of acidity described above. In some areas of the United States, the pH of rainwater can be 3.0 or lower, approximately 1000 times more acidic than normal rainwater. In 1982, the pH of a fog on the West Coast of the United States was measured at 1.8! When rainwater is too acidic, it can cause problems ranging from killing freshwater fish and damaging crops, to eroding buildings and monuments.
Questions on Acidity of Rainwater
1. List two or more ways that you could test the acidity of a sample of rainwater.
2. Write a balanced chemical equation for the dissociation of nitric acid in water. (HINT: Draw an analogy with Equation 2.)
3. The gaseous oxides found in the atmosphere, including CO2 and NO are nonmetal oxides. What would happen to the pH of rainwater if the atmosphere contained metal oxides instead? (HINT: Think back to Experiment 1.) Briefly, explain your answer.
Sources of Excess Acidity in Rainwater
What causes such a dramatic increase in the acidity of rain relative to pure water? The answer lies within the concentrations of nitric oxide and sulfur dioxide in polluted air. As shown in Table II and Figure 1, the concentrations of these oxides are much higher than in clean air.
0.1 - 2.0 ppm
Humans cause many combustion processes that dramatically increase the concentrations of acid-producing oxides in the atmosphere. Although CO2 is present in a much higher concentration than NO and SO2, CO2 does not form acid to the same extent as the other two gases. Thus, a large increase in the concentration of NO and SO2 significantly affects the pH of rainwater, even though both gases are present at much lower concentration than CO2.
Comparison of the concentrations of NO and SO2 in clean and polluted air.
About one-fourth of the acidity of rain is accounted for by nitric acid (HNO3). In addition to the natural processes that form small amounts of nitric acid in rainwater, high-temperature air combustion, such as occurs in car engines and power plants, produces large amounts of NO gas. This gas then forms nitric acid via Equations 4 and 5. Thus, a process that occurs naturally at levels tolerable by the environment can harm the environment when human activity causes the process (e.g., formation of nitric acid) to occur to a much greater extent.
What about the other 75% of the acidity of rain? Most is accounted for by the presence of sulfuric acid (H2SO4) in rainwater. Although sulfuric acid may be produced naturally in small quantities from biological decay and volcanic activity (Figure 1), it is produced almost entirely by human activity, especially the combustion of sulfur-containing fossil fuels in power plants. When these fossil fuels are burned, the sulfur contained in them reacts with oxygen from the air to form sulfur dioxide (SO2). Combustion of fossil fuels accounts for approximately 80% of the total atmospheric SO2 in the United States. The effects of burning fossil fuels can be dramatic: in contrast to the unpolluted atmospheric SO2 concentration of 0 to 0.01 ppm, polluted urban air can contain 0.1 to 2 ppm SO2, or up to 200 times more SO2! Sulfur dioxide, like the oxides of carbon and nitrogen, reacts with water to form sulfuric acid (Equation 6).
Sulfuric acid is a strong acid, so it readily dissociates in water, to give an H+ ion and an HSO4- ion (Equation 7). The HSO4- ion may further dissociate to give H+ and SO42- (Equation 8). Thus, the presence of H2SO4 causes the concentration of H+ ions to increase dramatically, and so the pH of the rainwater drops to harmful levels.
Questions on Sources of Acidity in Rainwater
4. At sea level and 25oC, one mole of air fills a volume of 24.5 liters, and the density of air is 1.22x10-6 g/ml. Compute the mole fraction (i.e., moles of component /total moles) and molarity of SO2 when the atmospheric concentration of SO2 is 2.0 ppm (see note in Table I).
5. One strategy for limiting the amount of acid pollution in the atmosphere is scrubbing. In particular, calcium oxide (CaO) is injected into the combustion chamber of a power plant, where it reacts with the sulfur dioxide produced, to yield solid calcium sulfite.
a. Write a balanced chemical equation for this reaction. (HINT: Consult the table of common ions in the tutorial assignment for Experiment 1 to view the structure and formula for sulfite; also, use your knowledge of the periodic table to deduce the charge of the calcium ion. Using these facts, you can deduce the formula for calcium sulfite.)
b. Approximately one ton, or 9.0x102 kg, of calcium sulfite is generated each year for every person served by a power plant. How much sulfur dioxide (in moles) is prevented from entering the atmosphere when this much calcium sulfite is generated? Show your calculation.
c. The final stage in the scrubbing process is to treat the combustion gases with a slurry of solid CaO in water, in order to trap any remaining SO2 and convert it to calcium sulfite. A slurry is a thick suspension of an insoluble precipitate in water. Using the solubility guidelines provided in the lab manual for this experiment, predict whether this stage of the scrubbing process will produce a slurry (i.e., precipitate) or a solution (i.e., no precipitate) of calcium sulfite .
d. If MgO, rather than CaO, were used for scrubbing, would the product of the final stage be a slurry or a solution of magnesium sulfite? (Assume that a very large quantity of magnesium sulfite, relative to the amount of water, is produced.)
Environmental Effects of Acid Rain
Acid rain triggers a number of inorganic and biochemical reactions with deleterious environmental effects, making this a growing environmental problem worldwide.
Many lakes have become so acidic that fish cannot live in them anymore.
Degradation of many soil minerals produces metal ions that are then washed away in the runoff, causing several effects:
The release of toxic ions, such as Al3+, into the water supply.
The loss of important minerals, such as Ca2+, from the soil, killing trees and damaging crops.
Atmospheric pollutants are easily moved by wind currents, so acid-rain effects are felt far from where pollutants are generated.
Stone Buildings and Monuments in Acid Rain
Marble and limestone have long been preferred materials for constructing durable buildings and monuments. The Saint Louis Art Museum, the Parthenon in Greece, the Chicago Field Museum, and the United States Capitol building are all made of these materials. Marble and limestone both consist of calcium carbonate (CaCO3), and differ only in their crystalline structure. Limestone consists of smaller crystals and is more porous than marble; it is used more extensively in buildings. Marble, with its larger crystals and smaller pores, can attain a high polish and is thus preferred for monuments and statues. Although these are recognized as highly durable materials, buildings and outdoor monuments made of marble and limestone are now being gradually eroded away by acid rain.
How does this happen? A chemical reaction (Equation 9) between calcium carbonate and sulfuric acid (the primary acid component of acid rain) results in the dissolution of CaCO3 to give aqueous ions, which in turn are washed away in the water flow.
This process occurs at the surface of the buildings or monuments; thus acid rain can easily destroy the details on relief work (e.g., the faces on a statue), but generally does not affect the structural integrity of the building. The degree of damage is determined not only by the acidity of the rainwater, but also by the amount of water flow that a region of the surface receives. Regions exposed to direct downpour of acid rain are highly susceptible to erosion, but regions that are more sheltered from water flow (such as under eaves and overhangs of limestone buildings) are much better preserved. The marble columns of the emperors Marcus Aurelius and Trajan, in Rome, provide a striking example: large volumes of rainwater flow directly over certain parts of the columns, which have been badly eroded; other parts are protected by wind effects from this flow, and are in extremely good condition even after nearly 2000 years!
Even those parts of marble and limestone structures that are not themselves eroded can be damaged by this process (Equation 9). When the water dries, it leaves behind the ions that were dissolved in it. When a solution containing calcium and sulfate ions dries, the ions crystallize as CaSO4l 2H2O, which is gypsum. Gypsum is soluble in water, so it is washed away from areas that receive a heavy flow of rain. However, gypsum accumulates in the same sheltered areas that are protected from erosion, and attracts dust, carbon particles, dry-ash, and other dark pollutants. This results in blackening of the surfaces where gypsum accumulates.
An even more serious situation arises when water containing calcium and sulfate ions penetrates the stone's pores. When the water dries, the ions form salt crystals within the pore system. These crystals can disrupt the crystalline arrangement of the atoms in the stone, causing the fundamental structure of the stone to be disturbed. If the crystalline structure is disrupted sufficiently, the stone may actually crack. Thus, porosity is an important factor in determining a stone's durability.
Questions on Effects of Acid Rain
6. Based on the information described above about the calcium ion, and the formula of calcium carbonate (CaCO3), deduce the charge of the carbonate ion. Also, in the structure of the carbonate ion, are any of the oxygens bonded to one another, or all the oxygens bonded to the carbon atom? (HINT: Consult the structure of the common ions given in the tutorial for Experiment 1).
7. In water, H2SO4 can dissociate to yield two H+ ions and one SO42- ion. Write the net ionic equation for the reaction of calcium carbonate and sulfuric acid. (See the introduction to Experiment 2 in the lab manual for a discussion of net ionic equations.)
8. Which is a more durable building material, limestone or marble? Briefly, explain your reasoning.
Click here to view the U.S. Geological Survey's excellent site on acid rain.
The Environmental Protection Agency's site on acid rain presents the basics of this problem in an accessible format.
The National Atmospheric Deposition Program features isopleth maps showing the concentrations of many different pollutants throughout the country.
Another very interesting EPA site on acid rain explains the novel "allowance trading system" strategy for getting companies to control their sulfur dioxide emissions.
Brown, Lemay, and Buster. Chemistry: the Central Science, 7th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1997. p. 673-5.
Charola, A. "Acid Rain Effects on Stone Monuments," J. Chem. Ed. 64 (1987), p. 436-7.
Petrucci and Harwood. General Chemistry: Principles and Modern Applications, 7th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1997. p. 614-5.
Walk, M. F. and P.J. Godfrey. "Effects of Acid Deposition on Surface Waters," J. New England Water Works Assn. Dec. 1990, p. 248-251.
Zumdahl, S.. Chem. Principles, 3rd ed. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1998. p. 174-6.
Stryer, L. Biochemistry, 4th ed., W.H. Freeman and Co., New York, 1995, p. 332-339.
The authors thank Dewey Holten (Washington University) for many helpful suggestions in the writing of this tutorial.
The development of this tutorial was supported by a grant from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, through the Undergraduate Biological Sciences Education program, Grant HHMI# 71192-502004 to Washington University.
Copyright 1998, Washington University, All Rights Reserved.